Expansions of or changes to dimensionally nonconforming buildings or structures are not permitted except to the limited extent set forth below only.
A. Expansions or changes of a totally nonconforming building or structure that has one or more dimensional nonconformity may be changed or expanded in order to fully, or more fully, conform with all applicable dimensional requirements for the zone in which such nonconforming building or structure is located. The total area of the totally nonconforming building or structure may, at the same time, be increased provided that the expanded area shall not exceed a cumulative maximum of 50% of the footprint of the totally nonconforming building or structure.
(1) Illustration. If a building or structure is located on a property in such a way that the building or structure is totally nonconforming, dimensionally (i.e., e.g., where the structure is entirely within the scenic road set-back) the building or structure may be modified to such that the nonconforming area is reduced. For example, a porch area that is encroaching into the setback by 20 feet may be modified such that the encroachment is lessened to 10 feet. If the totally nonconforming building or structure has a footprint area of 500 square feet, the total, cumulative maximum expansion shall not exceed 250 square feet. In no instance may the dimensional nonconformity be increased, meaning that the encroachment shall not be increased. Therefore, where a porch area that is encroaching into the setback by 20 feet, it may not be expanded so that any portion of the porch area encroaches 21 feet.
B. Buildings and structures with partial dimensional nonconformities, that is, if a building or structure is located on a property in such a way that the building or structure is only "partially" conforming and "partially" nonconforming, (for example where a setback line runs "through" the building or structure), the partially nonconforming building or structure may be expanded to a cumulative maximum of 50% of the footprint area of that portion of the building or structure that is partially dimensionally nonconforming, provided that no new nonconformities are created by the expansion or change. Buildings or structures with more than one floor will be permitted to expand vertically provided that the second floor has a footprint equal to, or less than the footprint of the first floor. Those areas or portions of buildings and structures with partial dimensional nonconformities that are not within the dimensionally nonconforming area may be expanded in conformity with all other limitations in this chapter without area limitations.
(1) Illustration 1. If a building with a 1,000 square foot footprint is encroaching in the side yard set back by 10 feet, with the area of encroachment being 500 square feet, the nonconforming structure may be expanded by up to 250 square feet (i.e., 50% of the 500 square feet), (not 500 square feet 50% of the total area of the building including the conforming areas), provided that the expansion stays within the existing ten-foot encroachment and all other limitations in this chapter are also met.
(2) Illustration 2. If a building with a 1,000 square foot footprint has a second floor, each of which is encroaching in the side yard set back by 10 feet, with the area of encroachment being 500 square feet, each floor of the nonconforming structure may be expanded by up to 250 square feet (i.e., 50% of the 500 square feet per floor) provided that the expansion stays within the existing ten-foot encroachment and all other limitations in this chapter are also met.
(3) Illustration 3. If a building is encroaching in the front yard set back by 10 feet, the rear portion of this partially nonconforming structure may be expanded without limitation in area so long as the expanded area is in total conformity with all other limitations in this chapter.
C. No expansions or extensions otherwise permitted hereby may be made within or into dimensionally restricted areas if the expansion will be in greater violation of the dimensional limitation.
(1) Illustration 1. If a building is encroaching in the side yard by 10 feet, a proposed expansion of the nonconforming structure shall be prohibited if the expansion will encroach greater than 10 feet even if the maximum expansion has not been met or exceeded.
(2) Illustration 2. If a building encroaches into a ten-foot side yard by two feet, no expansion can encroach further than two feet.
D. A building or structure that is dimensionally nonconforming because of its height shall not be expanded to increase its height.
E. Any expansion of a structure that has multiple floors will be reviewed on a floor by floor basis for conformity.
(1) Illustration 1. If a nonconforming building encroaches by 10 square feet on each of three floors, the building may not be expanded by more than five square feet on each of the three floors; the total expansion cannot be accumulated and the total of 15 square feet of expansion cannot be applied to one or two floors of the structure. Each floor is to be examined separately and has a cumulative maximum expansion of five feet per floor.
F. A lot or parcel of land that is nonconforming by number of dwelling units may not be expanded with the addition of a building or structure containing more dwelling units.